Log in

Russia & Taliban

July 03, 2020 11:00 AM | Margaret Hill (Administrator)

Why is Moscow paying the Taliban to kill Americans? 
by Mark Katz, Kennan Institute Scholar, Wilson Center; Political Science Professor George Mason University, Atlantic Council member

The following article was written by Dr. Mark N. Katz who spoke for a World Affairs Council Inland Southern California program that was held at University of Redlands on January 14, 2020. 

Citing U.S. intelligence sources, numerous media outlets have been reporting with increasing certainty that a Russian military intelligence unit has been — perhaps as far back as early 2019 — paying bounties to Taliban forces to target American and British forces in Afghanistan. Both Democrats and Republicans in Congress are expressing outrage over this. The White House and the Intelligence Community (often via retired officials) are engaged in a debate about when or even whether President Trump was briefed about this matter.

As reports about the Russian bounty payments  become increasingly definitive, how the U.S. should respond is becoming hotly debated. But in order to adequately formulate policy responses to Russian actions, another question needs to be addressed: Why would Russian intelligence go to the trouble of making bounty payments to the Taliban for attacking U.S. and coalition forces when this is something that the Taliban has long shown itself willing and able to do at its own expense? In other words, why pay someone to do something that they are already doing anyway?

Even as the U.S. Government appears to be increasingly certain that Russian military intelligence has made these bounty payments to the Taliban, it is doubtful that we will be able to definitively determine why it has done so any time soon. But there are several possibilities that can be explored — some of which may be more emotional than rational.

Some observers see Moscow doing this as revenge for the losses that the Kremlin-backed Wagner group (a Russian private military force) suffered in a firefight with U.S. forces in Syria in February 2018. Both the U.S. and Russia played down the incident at the time (indeed, the Kremlin disavowed that Wagner was operating at the behest of the Russian government) as neither wanted it to escalate into a broader U.S.-Russian confrontation. 

But this event may well have enraged the Kremlin, and so it may have decided to retaliate in a way that was plausibly deniable in order to avoid the risk of direct confrontation. It is not clear, though, whether these bounty payments began before or after the February 2018 firefight in Syria.

Another possibility is that Moscow sees its support for the Taliban as reciprocal retaliation for previous U.S. support to the Afghan mujahidin fighting Soviet occupation forces in the 1980s.  From Putin’s viewpoint, past U.S. support for Afghan jihadist forces fighting against the USSR opened the door for present Russian support for their Taliban successors fighting against the U.S.

But as powerful as the Kremlin’s desire to “do unto Washington what Washington did unto Moscow” may be, it may not explain why Russian intelligence would go to the trouble of paying the Taliban to do something that it was already doing anyway. Moreover, while we still don’t know the full timeline of when these payments began, why start now? The U.S. has been in Afghanistan for nearly two decades. It appears more probable that immediate Russian policy concerns may have motivated this.

One may be a Russian desire to curry favor with the Taliban. If the U.S. and its allies are going to leave Afghanistan anyway, then Russian support for the Taliban now may be seen in Moscow as laying the basis for establishing good working relations if the Taliban comes to power throughout Afghanistan soon thereafter. Establishing good relations now can help Moscow persuade the Taliban once it establishes control in Afghanistan not to act against Russian interests in Central Asia or elsewhere.

Another possibility is that Moscow fears U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad’s talks with the Taliban about an Afghan peace settlement will be so successful that something of a détente may emerge. A Taliban regime no longer fighting against the U.S. could then focus is attention on harming Russian interests. 

This scenario may seem outlandish, but permanently impairing U.S.-Taliban relations (whether the U.S. stays or leaves Afghanistan) by egging on Taliban attacks against U.S. and coalition forces may seem like a reasonable way to prevent it from turning against Russia. In addition, if Russian-backed Taliban attacks on U.S. forces lead to the breakdown of U.S.-led Afghan peace initiatives, Moscow may hope that this will open the door to a Russian-led one.

It’s even possible that Moscow has been encouraging Taliban attacks against U.S. and coalition forces not to hasten their withdrawal, but to motivate them to stay and fight. For so long as U.S. and coalition forces remain in Afghanistan, their presence actually serves to lessen the Taliban’s capacity for supporting groups similar to it in Central Asia — as they did prior to 9/11 when the Taliban played host not just to al-Qaida, but to the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (which actually launched raids from Afghanistan into neighboring Central Asian republics). If the U.S. and its allies leave Afghanistan, Moscow would have to confront this problem directly itself should it arise.

In short, Russian intelligence may have paid bounties to the Taliban to target U.S. and coalition forces in Afghanistan not just in response to Putin’s hostility toward the U.S. or his differences with the U.S. in Syria, but to further specific Russian aims in Afghanistan and Central Asia. But whatever the U.S. response is, it’s important we know what has motivated Putin to act, otherwise the U.S. risks another self-inflicted counterproductive foreign policy initiative that harms American interests.  

This article originally appeared in Responsible Statecraft a publication of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft on June 30, 2020.

Comments

  • July 09, 2020 5:36 PM | Mayprof
    Cephalexin Dose For Canines unfaiz https://acialisd.com/# - buy cialis online cheap Hibcittify Viagra Besoin Ordonnance Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>Cialis</a> axoxia Cialis Dall'Europa
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 11, 2020 6:50 AM | Mayprof
    Nuevo Progreso Mexico Pharmacies unfaiz https://acialisd.com/# - cialis canada Hibcittify Buying Finasteride Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>safe cialis online</a> axoxia Viagra Soft 20 Mg
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 11, 2020 7:35 AM | Mayprof
    Cephalexin Fir Strep DopeBofs https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Cialis Uphone Cialis Professional On Line ImponO <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>Cialis</a> peestyBots buy cialis 20 mg
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 12, 2020 10:33 PM | Mayprof
    Cialis Commenti unfaiz https://acialisd.com/# - generic cialis online europe Hibcittify Preis Cialis 20 Mg 12 Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>Cialis</a> axoxia Amoxicillin Given For How Many Days
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 12, 2020 10:51 PM | Mayprof
    Effets Cialis Viagra DopeBofs https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Buy Cialis Uphone Propecia Adverse Effects Discontinued ImponO <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>cialis coupons</a> peestyBots Where I Can Buy Ropinirole 2
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 13, 2020 5:20 AM | Mayprof
    Cialis Lilly Prix FriexZiree https://ascialis.com/# - Cialis Fliemo magasin levitra 20mg Unlime <a href=https://ascialis.com/#>Cialis</a> eagergeshosy Amoxil 500mg $0.29 Unit Price
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 13, 2020 9:15 AM | Mayprof
    para que sirve cialis 20 mg unfaiz https://acialisd.com/# - Cialis Hibcittify Azithromycin 250mg Canada Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>Cialis</a> axoxia hipertension y viagra
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 14, 2020 1:28 PM | Mayprof
    viagra cialis sample paypal unfaiz [url=https://acialisd.com/#]Cialis[/url] Hibcittify Parkizol Online Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>Cialis</a> axoxia Where Can I Buy Cyproheptadine
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 14, 2020 8:14 PM | Mayprof
    Bactrim No Prescriptio DopeBofs https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Cialis Uphone Cialis Sin Receta ImponO <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>Buy Cialis</a> peestyBots dosis kamagra oral jelly
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 16, 2020 3:37 AM | Mayprof
    Generic Real Isotretinoin Best Website C.O.D. Cheapeast Shop unfaiz https://acialisd.com/# - generic cialis for sale Hibcittify Ceclor And Keflex Nenaliella <a href=https://acialisd.com/#>cialis vs viagra</a> axoxia Propecia Guia
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 16, 2020 12:22 PM | Mayprof
    Belize Pharmacy At Port FriexZiree https://ascialis.com/# - cheap cialis Fliemo Kamagra Jelly 100mg Unlime <a href=https://ascialis.com/#>buy cialis</a> eagergeshosy levitra 20mg club
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 16, 2020 6:10 PM | Mayprof
    50mg cialis DopeBofs https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Buy Cialis Uphone Levitra Acidez ImponO <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>Buy Cialis</a> peestyBots Cialis Commande Rapide
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 16, 2020 9:00 PM | Mayprof
    Amoxicillin And Hives FriexZiree [url=https://ascialis.com/#]generic cialis vs cialis[/url] Fliemo discount generic cialis Unlime <a href=https://ascialis.com/#>Cialis</a> eagergeshosy Viamedic Complaints
    Link  •  Reply
  • July 19, 2020 3:37 AM | Alterse
    Levitra Precios DopeBofs https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Cialis Uphone cialis 20g ImponO <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>Buy Cialis</a> peestyBots Tadalafil 5mg Buy Online India
    Link  •  Reply
  • August 24, 2020 10:18 AM | Otilia
    natural cialis substitutes when does the patent for cialis expire cialis tadalafil
    buy online daily use of cialis cialis cheap online
    Link  •  Reply
  • August 24, 2020 12:04 PM | Bernd
    buy brand viagra canada what happens if women take viagra non prescription viagra alternative canada
    viagra online prescription what happens if you take viagra without ed
    Link  •  Reply
  • August 25, 2020 11:27 PM | 36 hour cialis online
    Cialis En Pharmacie FriexZiree https://biracialism.com/ - Cialis Fliemo viagra para hombres venta Unlime <a href=https://biracialism.com/#>buy cialis online safely</a> eagergeshosy us cialis pharmacy
    Link  •  Reply
  • August 26, 2020 4:33 PM | Jaclyn
    cialis 100 cialis dosing options buy cialis online without prescription buy cialis doctor online comprar
    cialis 5mg online
    Link  •  Reply

CONTACT
World Affairs Council of
Inland Southern California
11161 Anderson St., Suite 105-PMB 10009
Loma Linda, CA 92354

Office Phone: 909-558-7446
wacinlandsocal@gmail.com